I'd like to think that I'm a good decision-maker, in terms of weighing costs and benefits, and trying to really think through issues before making a decision. I think I do this fairly well, though the part about my decision-making I've never been wild about is though I think I weigh things carefully, I'm often not firm in my decision. I will decide one thing, and then be swayed by something else that happens, and then change my mind. The overall process is good, but the 'final answer' will often change depending on new information I get.
I/we are in a similar situation now. Just when we were about to take our house off the market and stay put in New Haven for another year, we received an offer on our house. It wasn't a great offer to start off with, but after working with the potential buyers for the better part of the weekend, it came to be a mostly reasonable offer (except for a time late Sunday night when they made a completely unreasonable request and we walked away from the deal-making process).
This all sounds fabulous, and exactly what we have been waiting for, and it is. Except for two major things: 1) school starts this week up in Amherst (actually, orientation is this week and school starts Monday), and 2) we have begun visits to a private school in New Haven we like for both girls (we changed our minds about Foote and now are focusing on Cold Spring (www.coldspringschool.org). In fact, both girls have an interview there today. It would be nice to have both girls in one school, and in this system, they have a combined K/1 program, so Ella would spend two years in that grade (and technically repeat kindergarten, which is probably a good thing). However, the school isn't perfect: its a rather small building with no gym and it doesn't have its own playground, except for the park across the street. And, its not extremely convenient for us in terms of location. Perhaps most importantly, I fear that though I could afford it this year, I don't think I could afford it in upcoming years. Combined, it would cost about $30,000 to send both kids there for one year. But, its an excellent school and I think Ella would do well there academically.
Ultimately, our goal is to move to Amherst so that we can all be together, and I need to keep that in mind. Amherst is a wonderful community, and both Kim and I think the kids would really prosper there. It reminds both Kim and I of the places we grew up (Texas and Montana). Its very much a farming community in some ways, and we would really live the kind of life that we want to live, based in spending a lot of time outdoors and living in a community where people are generally a bit more accepting of gay and lesbian families. I don't feel NOT accepted in my workplace or in greater New Haven, but we still feel like total outsiders in our little neighborhood, and I am still amazed (though perhaps less shocked) that none of our neighbors really speak to us and that people drive by on our small cul-de-sac and don't wave or say hello. I guess that saddest part is that we have gotten used to it and it doesn't really bother us anymore, but on the other hand, I don't think its the way we want to live our lives.
So, ironically, we make a visit to Cold Spring around noon, and we need to make a final decision about the housing contract by the end of the day. At this point, I guess it could go either way, though the more I think about things, the more I think I'm leaning towards Amherst, primarily because I think its important for our family to be together, and if we don't take this opportunity now, we'll not all live together for another year, as we'd take the house off the market and just complete the school year here. But, I'm also open to having a good look at Cold Spring, and if Ella is really taken by the school and the teachers, then I think that will be instructive as well.
Its a big day, certainly. Wish us luck, and pray that we make the right decision.